A raw New York strip on a wooden board with rosemary, thyme, garlic, butter and a bowl of Montreal steak seasoning
Save

Recipes / Dinner

Sous Vide Steak

Edge-to-edge medium-rare New York strip, cooked sous vide with Montreal steak seasoning, rosemary, butter and garlic, then finished with a hard sear.

What's the Story

I take pride in my steak and the way I cook it. I know sous vide may be frowned upon by a lot of steak eaters, but the flavors really pop. I think it’s the best way to get all the flavor of a steakhouse into a steak at home, maybe even better.

How It Comes Together

Seasoned New York strip sealed in a sous vide bag with rosemary, butter and garlic
  1. Season.

    I season a 1½ to 2-inch New York strip with McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning.

  2. Bag it.

    Into the bag it goes with a rosemary sprig, a pat of butter and pressed garlic on each side.

  3. Cook sous vide.

    It cooks at 131°F for medium rare. A 1½-inch steak takes about 1½ to 2 hours; a 2-inch steak about 2½ to 3 hours.

The steak searing in a hot cast iron skillet, turned with tongs
  1. Pat it dry.

    I take the steak out of the bag and pat it completely dry.

  2. Salt again.

    I hit it with a little more salt right before searing; it helps build a great crust.

  3. Sear hard and fast.

    I get a skillet as hot as I can with a high-heat oil like avocado or coconut oil, and sear each side for 30 seconds to 1 minute.

Ingredients for Sous Vide Steak laid out on a cutting board: a seasoned New York strip, rosemary, thyme, garlic and butter

What Each Ingredient Brings

  • New York strip: My favorite cut. It has a good amount of fat but also a good amount of leanness, which suits me since I'm more of a lean eater. Use whichever cut you prefer.
  • Rosemary, butter and pressed garlic: Infuse the steak with rich, aromatic flavor while it cooks in the bag. I press the garlic rather than mincing it.
  • Avocado or coconut oil: High smoke point, so the pan can get screaming hot without burning.

Seasonings

  • McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning: My favorite steak seasoning; bold, peppery and garlicky.
  • Extra salt before searing: Helps form a deep crust.

What I Learned Making It

  • Pat the steak completely dry before searing. Otherwise it will steam instead of crust.
  • A quick, very hot sear is all it needs. The inside is already perfectly cooked.
  • Give thick steaks enough time. Sous vide makes it hard to overcook, but give thick steaks enough time for the center to fully reach temperature, and don't go much past 4 hours at 131°F.

Steak Doneness

DonenessSous vide tempWhat it looks like
Blue / very rare115–120°FCool, deep red center
Rare120–128°FRed, very soft
Medium rare (my pick: 131°F)129–134°FWarm pink-red center, juicy
Medium135–144°FPink center, firmer
Medium well145–155°FSlightly pink, firm
Well done156°F and upNo pink, firmest

Thickness and Cook Time (at 131°F)

Steak thicknessMinimum timeRecommended range
1 inch1 hour1 to 1½ hours
1½ inches1½ hours1½ to 2 hours
2 inches2½ hours2½ to 3 hours

These are from the fridge. Avoid going much past 4 hours at medium-rare temperatures.

Steak Cuts, Fatty to Lean

CutFat levelNotes
RibeyeHighHeavily marbled, rich and buttery
T-bone / PorterhouseMedium-highStrip and filet on one bone
New York strip (my favorite)MediumBalance of fat and lean, beefy flavor
SirloinLow-mediumLean, budget-friendly
Filet mignonLowVery lean and tender, mild flavor
Flank / SkirtLowLean, best sliced thin against the grain
Sliced medium-rare sous vide steak with a dark seared crust on a wooden board

Final Thoughts

This is probably the best steak I've ever eaten. You can go to a steakhouse and you won't get the same flavor, no matter how aged the steak may be.

Sous Vide Steak

Cook
1½–3 hr, plus a 1–2 min sear
Makes
1 per steak

Ingredients

Per steak

  • 1 New York strip, 1½ to 2 inches thick
  • 2 sprigs fresh rosemary
  • 2 pats butter
  • 2 garlic cloves, pressed
  • Avocado or coconut oil, for searing

Seasonings (per steak)

  • 3/4 tsp McCormick Montreal Steak Seasoning
  • Extra salt, for searing

Method

  1. Season the steak with Montreal Steak Seasoning.
  2. Bag it with a rosemary sprig, a pat of butter and pressed garlic on each side.
  3. Cook sous vide at 131°F for medium rare: about 1½ to 2 hours for a 1½-inch steak, 2½ to 3 hours for a 2-inch steak.
  4. Take the steak out of the bag and pat it completely dry.
  5. Salt it again right before searing.
  6. Sear in a smoking-hot skillet with avocado or coconut oil, 30 seconds to 1 minute per side.

Shopping list

Check your pantry

#sous vide#steak#beef

Goes well with

I serve it over The Best Mashed Potatoes (my smoked Gouda mashed potatoes) as a base, with Red Wine Reduction and Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms. Together they make my Steakhouse Dinner at Home.