Glass bowl of whole dark balsamic marinated mushrooms on a wooden board
Save

Recipes / Sides

Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms

Baby bella mushrooms roasted with olive oil, garlic and fresh thyme, then marinated in aged balsamic for 24 hours until dark and glossy.

What's the Story

I wanted something to complement my steak, and I love mushrooms. They’re a big staple for me: they taste great and they’re good for you. These went perfectly with a sous vide steak.

How It Comes Together

Baby bella mushrooms with thyme sprigs in a cast iron skillet before roasting
  1. Oil the mushrooms.

    I toss the baby bella mushrooms in olive oil in an oven-safe skillet.

  2. Add garlic and thyme.

    Minced garlic and fresh thyme sprigs go in, and I toss everything to coat.

The skillet of mushrooms roasting in the oven
  1. Roast.

    They roast at 375–425°F for 15–25 minutes, until they shrink and brown.

Roasted, browned mushrooms with thyme in the cast iron skillet
  1. Toss with the balsamic.

    The roasted mushrooms get tossed with the balsamic marinade.

  2. Jar and wait.

    I spoon them into a mason jar and refrigerate them for 24 hours before serving so they soak up the marinade.

Ingredients for Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms laid out on a counter: baby bella mushrooms, olive oil, balsamic vinegar and small bowls of seasonings

What Each Ingredient Brings

  • Baby bella mushrooms: Earthy and meaty; they roast down into bite-size morsels.
  • Extra-virgin olive oil: Helps the mushrooms brown and gives the marinade its richness.
  • Fresh thyme: A woodsy, herbal note.
  • Garlic: Savory depth in the roast and a little bite in the marinade.
  • Aged balsamic vinegar: Sweet, tangy and slightly syrupy; the star of the marinade.
Spices and seasonings for Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms: salt, fresh thyme and garlic beside the balsamic and olive oil

Seasonings

  • Salt and pepper: Season the mushrooms and sharpen every other flavor.

What I Learned Making It

  • Baby bellas are the right mushroom. I like their size and shape, and they shrink a little in the oven into bite-size morsels of flavor that burst in your mouth.
  • Give them a full 24 hours. A full day in the fridge means they're ready for the next day.
  • Not all balsamic is the same. Some are thin and runny. I stick with a traditional, aged balsamic made from grapes, which is thicker and slightly syrupy. If yours is runny, simmer it in a small saucepan until it coats a spoon.
  • Why aged balsamic? It reminds me of my trip to Italy, where I visited Casa di Emma. They had some of the best balsamic vinegar I've ever tried.
  • Want a twist? Try a flavored balsamic, like raspberry.

Questions

How long do they keep?
3–4 days in the fridge.
Do I serve them cold or warm?
Either. Serve them cold, or warm them up.
What do I serve them with?
Steak, especially my Steakhouse Dinner at Home, or on a charcuterie board for an earthy, tangy bite.

Final Thoughts

These tasty little morsels are a delight and a treat, bursting with flavor from the thyme, garlic and balsamic. They're a perfect side for a lot of occasions, not just steak but charcuterie too, or just keep them in the fridge and pop one in your mouth every once in a while.

Balsamic Marinated Mushrooms

Serves
6
Batch

Ingredients

For the mushrooms

  • 8 oz whole baby bella (cremini) mushrooms
  • 3 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil
  • 5 sprigs fresh thyme
  • 2 cloves garlic, finely minced

Seasonings

  • 1 tsp kosher salt
  • 1 tbsp freshly cracked pepper

For the marinade

  • 4 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil
  • 3 tbsp aged balsamic vinegar
  • 2 cloves garlic, crushed

Method

  1. Toss the mushrooms with olive oil, garlic and thyme in an oven-safe skillet.
  2. Roast at 375–425°F for 15–25 minutes.
  3. Toss with the balsamic.
  4. Transfer to a mason jar and refrigerate 24 hours.

Storage: Fridge 3–4 days.

Shopping list

Check your pantry

#mushrooms#balsamic#marinated#make ahead

Goes well with

You might also like